Nov. 19, 2026 · 8 min read
Questions at the mic: Smithfield's neighborhood meeting, in plain words
Smithfield held the neighborhood meeting a judge said it skipped. The auditorium at Southeast Tech was full. Here's what Smithfield presented, what neighbors asked, which answers are still coming and what happens next.

The auditorium at Southeast Tech was full Thursday night. Some people came from Crooks and Renner. Some live a mile from the site. Some live a mile from the plant downtown.
They all came for the same reason. Smithfield wants to build a new pork plant at Foundation Park in northwest Sioux Falls. Tonight was the neighborhood meeting a judge said it should have held the first time.
You don't have to be for it or against it to want to understand it. Here's what I heard.


Why this meeting happened
In March, the City Council approved Smithfield's conditional use permit. Neighbors near Foundation Park sued. In October, a judge sent the permit back to the Council. One reason: the required neighborhood meeting never happened.
That meeting is meant to cover how a plant fits next to homes. Building design. Screening. Landscaping. Buffer space.
Jim Monroe of Smithfield led the panel. Smithfield's project engineer walked through the plan. Mark Cotter from Sioux Falls Public Works answered road questions. A moderator ran a two-minute clock at two microphones.
What Smithfield presented
These are Smithfield's numbers and plans, as shown Thursday.
- The site. About 210 acres. Smithfield says more than half would stay open or green.
- Distance from homes. The hog barn, rendering, water treatment and truck access would sit on the south and southeast side, farthest from homes. Smithfield plans to keep mature trees and build a 10-foot landscaped berm on the north side.
- Everything indoors. Covered unloading. An enclosed barn where hogs wait a few hours before processing. No outdoor pens or piles. The engineer put the most hogs on site at one time at about 8,500.
- Odor. Air from key areas would go through scrubbers and a unit that burns exhaust at about 1,500 degrees.
- Trucks. About 85% would come off I-29. About 15% from the south on Marion Road. Trucks and employees would use separate entrances.
- Water. Smithfield says the plant is designed around 3.2 million gallons a day at most, with a valve that caps how much it can draw. Process water would be treated on site in tanks and buildings, with no open lagoons, then piped to the Big Sioux River under a state permit. The engineer said that would be farther downstream than today. The exact spot isn't set.
- Timing. Monroe said they're aiming to open in late 2028, if permits come through.

What neighbors asked
The questions came fast. Here are the big ones, in plain words.
Smell. This was the biggest worry. One neighbor pointed to a newer rendering plant near Freeman, where residents still complain about odor. The engineer said he couldn't speak to that plant. He said Smithfield's plan starts with enclosing everything and capturing the air. He also cleared up one thing: there will be one rendering plant, not two.
Who holds them accountable. Several people asked who to call if it smells, or if something goes wrong. The engineer said the state air permit sets the limits and the state enforces them. Testing happens at the stacks on site. He said he wasn't aware of plans to monitor air out in the neighborhoods. Asked how neighbors would hear about a permit violation, he said he didn't know. For emergencies like an ammonia leak, he said the plant has 15 minutes to notify authorities.
Property values. Acreage owners within a mile or two asked what happens to their homes. Monroe said he understands the concern. He said Foundation Park was planned for heavy industry and many things affect property values.
Roads, dust and school buses. People from Crooks asked about trucks on two-lane roads, dust and kids on buses. Crooks' fire chief asked about Exit 86. Most of Smithfield's trucks would use it, and the state plans to rebuild that interchange around the same time the plant opens.
Water and health. A member of the East Dakota Water Development Board asked about runoff into a small creek that feeds Skunk Creek. A longtime nurse asked about health effects for kids at the nearby school. Smithfield said its stormwater plan is built to prevent runoff. Other health questions went on comment cards for written answers.
Jobs and money. Asked about jobs, Monroe said the number at the new plant isn't set but shouldn't be dramatically different from today. Smithfield says it has more than 3,000 workers in Sioux Falls now. Asked about public help, he said the project has a tax increment financing deal of about $90 million. He said Smithfield pays costs up front and is paid back over time, and the money goes toward the new water treatment plant.
Other questions covered why this site, what other sites were considered, Smithfield's ownership and the land's recent annexation. Monroe said Smithfield looked at other places, including out of state, but wouldn't say where.
What the City said about roads
Mark Cotter of Public Works said:
- Money. The City has budgeted about $6 million for road work serving Foundation Park and that whole area, not just Smithfield. Design is underway. Construction is planned for 2028.
- Exit 86. The state Department of Transportation plans to keep east-west traffic over the I-29 bridge open during the rebuild, along with the south ramps. The north ramps would close while they're rebuilt. The new bridge will have room for people walking.
- A new fire station. One is being built about two miles south. It's expected to open in 2027.
The state posts its Exit 86 plans on the SDDOT public meetings page, under the Metro Region.
Answers still coming
A lot of questions didn't get full answers Thursday. Smithfield asked people to put them on comment cards and promised written responses. These are the ones to watch:
- How much ammonia will be on site, and when the safety plan for it will be done
- Who pays for the road changes
- How neighbors will be told about a problem
- Whether anyone will monitor air out in the neighborhoods
When those answers come out, I'll share them here.

Where I stand
This part is my own opinion, not a summary of the meeting.
I spoke Thursday too. I'm a Smithfield kid. My parents came to Sioux Falls as refugees. They didn't know much English, and they didn't know anybody. Smithfield is where my dad could work and make a living, and it's how my family was able to open our own business.
Today the kids of Smithfield workers are lawyers, health care workers and business owners across Sioux Falls. I've said before that I support the move, and I still do. I live within a mile of the plant downtown. A Sioux Falls where that plant isn't in the middle of our city raised the ceiling on what I thought was possible.
I also thanked Smithfield for holding this meeting. It was the best-attended public meeting I've been to, and people got to say what they came to say.
Plenty of neighbors in that room see it differently. They live a lot closer to the new site than I do. Their questions are fair, and they deserve real answers. The Council makes the final call, and your voice counts there whether you agree with me or not.
What happens next
Smithfield says it will apply for the permit again. The new application goes to the Planning Commission first, then the City Council. Both hold public hearings, and you can speak on the record at either one.

I'll post the dates on our civic calendar and the Smithfield issue page as soon as they're set.
Until then:
- Ask Smithfield directly. corporateaffairs@smithfield.com
- Reach your Council members. Find them with our Neighborhood Guide or on Who Represents Sioux Falls.
- Get the update. The Rise will have the hearing date when it's set.
Get informed. Get heard. Get active.
Sources
- My own notes, photos and recording from Smithfield's neighborhood meeting, Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, The Hub, Southeast Technical College.
- Smithfield's presentation slides shown at the meeting.
- Judge sends Smithfield conditional use permit back to city, South Dakota News Watch.
- Minnehaha County judge rules Sioux Falls erred in Smithfield permit process, SiouxFalls.Business.
- Simplified: Parks, pork and public input, Sioux Falls Simplified.
Have a tip or a story idea? Email issues@risingtogethersf.com.
